This past July, over 100 alumni and friends came together to help celebrate 20 years of the HSRAA.

The Sump Pumps return performance help boost the 1960’s decade alumni attendance this year.

JB Rettew and Ron Sykes at the Goodman Pavilion.

Ann Babb, Becky Ekins & Sherry Seace

Gus Sauerzopf helps prepare the food line.

Alumni dinner served.

The Sump Pumps play the classics.

Rusty Morgan and his favorite ventriloquist, Jim Goudie, make a return appearance.

Jim Matthews and A.J. DiAntonio

Delivered on demand by the HSRAA board, the weather was absolutely perfect for the 19th Annual HSRAA Reunion held at Camp Horseshoe on July 7th. The atmospheric conditions, being unseasonably cool in the high 70s, assisted with the great turnout of approximately 110 registrants for the yearly festivities.

The theme of the reunion was “By Campfire’s Light Old Tales Retold”, and several speakers including Ernie Heegard, Andrew Coe, and HSRAA Chairman John Kemmerer regaled the audience with their memories of campfires at Horseshoe over the years. This particular theme was chosen, in part, to coincide with the HSRAA’s speculative future project to rehabilitate Achgeketum circle, with possible facets of the endeavor including additional benches for the adult seating area and improved rainwater management.

As part of the recent additions to the reunion program, a few participants competed for the coveted Masters Challenge trophy. The Masters Challenge, hosted by the Campcraft area, is a series of pioneering challenges including a heaving bar toss and knot relays. Campcraft Director Carter Miller announced after dinner that the 2018 winner was Mike D’Antonio.

Speaking of dinner… Tony Wetzel and Dick Bensing once again cooked up another fabulous steak dinner, accompanied by delicious Amish potato salad and treats from the Camp Horseshoe kitchen, including apple turnovers.

HSRAA Secretary Matt Griffin introduced the new HSRAA Scholarship for current camp staff members, with scholarships going to 1 staffer from each HSR camp based on an application and selection process.

VP of Camping Pete Motel delivered some remarks about the reforestation project conducted by Octoraro Lodge 22 (via sacrifice by Tom Murphy), as well as his optimism for Family Scouting – set to debut at HSR next year – being a success for all patrons of CCC.

Vice Chairman Damon Sinclair announced the recipients of the HSRAA Staff Member of the Year Award for both Camp Horseshoe and Camp Ware, with Richard “Booker” Gardner being the Horseshoe recipient, and William “Squigs” McGuigan being the recipient for Ware. Congratulations Booker and Squigs!

The Camp Horseshoe staff, led by Camp Director Dr. David Mellinger, provided a musical tribute to camp patrons who passed in the last year, including Karl “Moose” Winsch, Wayne Woodward, Bob Lorgus, Jimmy Jordan, and Ken Fegley. The musical composition was Beethoven’s “Adagio Cantabile”, delivered beautifully by flute and organ. Ernie Heegard also provided his musical talents at the end of the reunion, singing “Row, Row, Row Your Boat” in different musical times and styles.

After a quick business meeting with the election of the 2018-2019 HSRAA board members, many alumni and their families retreated to Achgeketum circle to watch in wonder at the pageantry of “The Legend of Cholena” and the recognition ceremony thereafter. Wedged in-between, the Octoraro Lodge 22 commenced a Vigil Honor Ceremony where 5 new Vigil Honor members were eventually bestowed their recognition the following morning.

The majesty and mystery of the HSR campfire is one of the things most fondly remembered by all who attend, and the Camp Horseshoe staff admirably delivered to the high standards of the tradition. “Old Tales Retold” is more than just a line in the lyrics of our locally-famous “The Loop of the Octoraro Bend”, it is the encapsulation of a waning tradition, that of the oral history. Whether it be through pageants at Achgeketum or ghost stories at individual campsites, HSR is rich in tradition of passing on the fantastic and the unbelievable through tall tales.

Next year’s reunion theme will be decided in the coming months, and for the 20th Annual Reunion you can expect some serious pomp and circumstance, but looking back at this past reunion let us

Over 100 HSR alumni came out to indulge in friendship, fun, and great food at the annual HSRAA Reunion celebrating Camp Horseshoe’s 90th year this past July. Reunion stalwarts such as J.B Rettew III and Jim Battenfelder were there, but other familiar faces like “Big Joe” Sivco also showed up.

Some reunion happenings: a huge cache of Ken Yeager’s Royal Order of Siam slides were scanned, and a camp tour conducted by Horseshoe staff brought all the alumni up to date. Former Campcraft Director and past HSRAA chairman, Bob Matje Jr., won the pioneering competition in the 2017 Masters’ Challenge, while Projects Chair Dick Bensing and Tony Wetzel provided an amazing steak dinner after the evening retreat on the parade field.

Dinner entertainment included the musical stylings of both Ernie Heegard and the Camp Horseshoe Choir. Dick Bensing provided a projects update of the landscaping project around the shower house, while Camp Directors Dr. Dave Mellinger and Bill Hohl honored the HSRAA Staff Members of the year: Steven “Mookie” Reich from Camp Horseshoe, and Sam Moore from Camp Ware. Congratulations to these dedicated staffers who are always striving to provide the best camper experience!

Longtime alumnus Joe Eagan was invited to speak about the formation of HSRAA nearly 20 years ago, and the critical need of such an organization for the survival of BSA camps. Examples of the projects and services HSRAA has provided benefiting Scouting in Chester County Council were provided. Eric Lorgus also took to the microphone to speak about his time as a camper and a staffer at Camp Horseshoe, with stories about Ernie to boot.

The alumni unanimously approved the slate of 2017- 2018 HSRAA board members, including a few new members like Ben Linskens, Richard “Stick” Smith, and Chris McConnell. Plus a few returning members including Andrew Coe and Andrew Smith.

As the sun dimmed over the Western loop of the Octoraro Creek, alumni found their way over to Achgeketum Circle to witness the OA pageant and see a new generation of Scouts recognized for their efforts throughout the week. The Saturday night campfire, much like the rest of the program, was a solemn reminder to the alumni, while the buildings and landscapes may change over time, the tradition and Spirit of Horseshoe always shines bright!

Over 80 Scouts, Scouters, volunteers and family members braved the muggy weather to join in the fun at the 17th Annual HSRAA Reunion held at both Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware 3rd on July 9th. With the theme “Investing in Our Future”, two key programs were highlighted during the reunion – the new Innovation Center at Camp Ware, and the Cub Day program being organized by Octoraro Lodge #22 and Chester County Council.

Participants hiked or drove over to Camp Ware to visit the new Innovation Center, which features 3D printer and laser etching as marquis attractions. The Innovation Center is housed in the shop area of the Handicraft Pavilion, and serves now as the hub of activity for these sought-activity programs.

The Camp Ware staff also guided the reunion participants over to Macaleer Lodge, which currently serves as the Nature Center during the summer camp season. All were treated to a few friendly captive snakes and walls adorned with lots of unique displays for Boy Scout and Cub Scout programs.

Before venturing back to Camp Horseshoe, HSRAA’s chairman John Kemmerer and Camp Ware Director Bill Hohl honored HSRAA Staff Member of the Year Will Warram for his more than 20 years of service to Camp Staff. Will served in many different departments, including Shooting Sports, Aquatics, and Maintenance.

Back at Horseshoe, reunion class photos were taken, with the decade groups going back as far as the 1930s. After viewing the evening retreat and OA callout ceremony, participants enjoyed a steak dinner cooked by Dick Bensing. Ernie Heegard got the crowd warmed up with a song (“Zumgali Gali”) after dinner, and the Horseshoe Choir gave an inspiring vocal and organ performance. Octoraro Lodge Vice Chief Luke Carstens took a few moments to discuss the upcoming Cub Day activity planned for October 2016, an event focused on Cub Scout retention by hosting a centrally-located carnival of fun games, crafts and camping.

The HSRAA board also honored as HSRAA Staff Member of the Year Dr. David Mellinger, long-time Health Officer for Camp Horseshoe and former Camp Jubliee (now Ware) Director. “Dr. Dave’s” service record as a staff member goes back over 30 years, and he has made an indelible impact on countless lives.

Scout Executive Charlie Rogers was invited to speak to the HSRAA audience, and he recognized Director of Camping Ray Hayden for his 15+ years of service to HSR in that capacity. Ray recently took a position with Philmont Scout Ranch as Director of Facilities and Maintenance.

Finally, HSRAA Chairman John Kemmerer conducted the favorite part of the HSRAA reunion – the annual business meeting. All nominees for the board were elected, including Dick Bensing, J.B. Rettew, Jake Segal, A.J. DiAntonio, Damon Sinclair, Steve Miller, Matt Griffin, Dave Woodward, and John himself.

Some participants then headed over to Achgeketum for the Saturday evening campfire, others stayed beyond that for the Vigil Honor Ceremony, and some even stayed long enough to visit Chapel for Sunday Faith Services the next day. But one thing’s for certain, no matter how many miles you walk on Horseshoe soil, the dust in the mocassins only keeps accumulating.

86 members and guests gathered at Camp Horseshoe on July 11th for the 16th annual Horseshoe Scout Reservation Alumni Association reunion. The theme, ‘Celebrating Milestones’, recognized the 100th anniversary of the Order of the Arrow and 250th anniversary of the Mason Dixon survey. You could not have asked for better weather as alumni from 9 decades began to arrive at 2pm for a day of reminiscing, good food and fellowship.

A camp tour included a stop at the Science Center located in Schramm Lodge. The Science Center, which opened in 2014, provides Scouts the opportunity to work on STEM-oriented Merit Badge throughout the week, such as Robotics, Nuclear Science, Electronics, Photography, Computers, Electricity, Energy, Moviemaking, Game Design, Engineering, and Space Exploration. Another stop at the OA Lodge showcased the history of our Octorara Lodge #22. The final stop was at the Mason Dixon marker where Price Stevenson provided the group with an overview of Charles Mason and Jeremiah Dixon’s historic survey.

‘Class/Decade’ pictures were taken late in the afternoon. Every decade beginning with the 1930s up until the 2010s were represented as the 60’s proved to have largest turnout.

After the retreat ceremony, everyone gathered back at the Goodman pavilion for dinner. Dick Bensing and company did a fantastic job of preparing steak with all the fixings and you can be sure, nobody went home hungry! As dinner was finishing up, the program was kicked off by the Reunion chairman and master of ceremonies, AJ DiAntonio.

Chester Council Council Scout Executive, Charlie Rogers commended the HSRAA for its continued support of the camp. The attendees were treated by members of the Horseshoe Choir and Ernie Heegard brought back memories of post-meal time at Allen Memorial Dining Hall as led the group in a song.

Camp Director, Mike ‘Berk’ Berkeihiser and many of the Horseshoe camp staff stopped by as this year’s HSRAA staff member of the year, Will Stevens, was recognized with a plaque and gift certificate. Will has worked on camp staff for many years as an aquatics counselor, aquatics director and for the past three years, Program Director.

Price Stevenson shared more of the Mason Dixon history and our OA Lodge Chief, Matt Candy, provided an update of Octoraro Lodge #22. Our lodge received the E. Urner Goodman Camping Award (8th time), the National Service Award (5th time) and the Innovation Award (1st time), only the second lodge in the country to be awarded all 3 in the same year. HSRAA President, John Kemmerer, high-lighted some of the HSRAA accomplishments of the past year including the storm water management, Picnic Grove renovation (when was the last time you remember seeing grass in the Picnic Grove!). John also thanked Dick Bensing and Ernie Heegard for their many contributions to HSR on behalf of the Alumni Association. The final business of the day was the election of the HSRAA board for the upcoming year which includes Dick Bensing, Neil Chippendale, A.J. DiAntonio, Matt Griffin, John Kemmerer, J.B. Rettew, Jake Segal, Damon Sinclair and Dave Woodward.

Alums representing nine different decades gathered at Camp Horseshoe on July 13th, 2013 to share in the special events of the day, enjoy time with old friends, and see the camps of the reservation in action. The day was declared as “Ron Sykes Day” in honor of this former camper and staff member’s past contributions to the lore of the camp. This year marked the 14th consecutive summer reunion; the event having been initiated in 2000, shortly after the founding of the HSRAA. While each year’s reunion has a slightly different schedule of events and a different group of attendees, the format generally includes afternoon socializing and camp tours, group photos, dinner, and an after-dinner program.

This year saw the addition of the inaugural Masters Challenge that had a cohort of the group competing in afternoon activities that involved coiling and throwing ropes, tying knots, starting fire with flint and steel and judging heights and distances. Tomahawk throwing was relegated to “exhibition” status this year but also drew considerable interest from the field. When the final scores were tallied, A.J. DiAntonio came out on top and took home bragging rights, along with a custom-made trophy hand-crafted in the tradition of the camp. Look for another staging of the Masters Challenge at a future reunion.

After a late-afternoon photo shoot (look in the HSRAA Virtual Museum for the results) most of the alums ventured across the Picnic Grove to take up viewing positions for the Saturday night retreat ceremony. This camp tradition continues in much the same way it has for years with the troops marching to the beat of the camp drum line and the camp bugler sounding the Retreat and To the Colors calls. And the cannon blast that used to punctuate the ceremony just as Old Glory begins her descent? Well, they still do that and the first-time viewers still jump with surprise when they hear it!

After Retreat and just prior to our dinner, a large contingent of the current camp staff made an appearance at our Goodman Pavilion locale for their participation in our program. First, this year’s Chapel Choir performed a hymn as part of our pre-meal blessing. Then, while the current staffers were still present, we presented another inaugural award: the HSRAA Camp Staff Member of the Year. The HSRAA Board decided to initiate this award as a way to highlight our mission by recognizing a current staff member who has made major contributions toward preserving and promoting the spirit and heritage of Horseshoe Scout Reservation and its camps. The 2013 award went to Josh Taylor. Josh has been a long-time staff member at Camp Horseshoe and served as Director of Field Sports in 2013. Look for another article, coming soon, with more on Josh and this new award.

Following a barbeque dinner that met, but did not exceed, expectations (spoiler alert – expect a new caterer next year), the group ended the repast with a sheet cake decorated with the new HSRAA patch design. Look for another article, also coming soon, with more about the patch and the story behind it. 

At the conclusion of dinner, we imposed on former Camp Horseshoe Director, Ernie Heegard, to lead us in song. He kindly complied and, in no time, had our group of modestly talented crooners working a three-part round to near-perfection. Scouts from the TV show, America’s Got Talent, were on hand but were unwilling to sign the group after the brief audition.

The after-dinner program also included the presentation of our Distinguished Alumni Award to Ron Sykes. Ron was a camper and staff member beginning in 1942. As detailed in 2012 and 2013 issues of our newsletter, The Octoraro Loop, Ron was instrumental in establishing some of the traditions that survive today. All in attendance were rapt in attention as Ron recounted some stories from the past.

In the fading twilight, the formal reunion program concluded. Alums were invited to stay and attend the Saturday Night Campfire with its traditional Indian Pageant and presentation of awards to the current batch of campers. With fond farewells all around and promises to see each other again at future reunions, the 2013 reunion concluded.

Another great Reunion for the Horseshoe Scout Reservation at the Goodman Pavilion!

Thanks to Damon Sinclair videos from our “ancient and honorable” film files offered those who were reuniting a chance to get a glimpse of Horseshoe’s early days of the 1930’s, ’40’s and ’88. We even had a chance to see some of our present day alumni who were filmed then and wow! what has happened since? We could view Ron Sykes (Handicraft Director in the ’40’s) applying his skills teaching the Scouts of another day; and, Ernie Heegard in an earlier day along with Johnny Rettew atop the lifeguard stand at the pool! My how our camp changed over the years but then again so have we all. No “Oscars” but a lot of fun and laughs seeing our Scouts and staff and camp at a different time.

In 1988 a lot was going on at Horseshoe in preparation for the arrival of 1200 Polish boy and girl scouts for their “Jamboree-in-exile” (more about this at a future Reunion and issue) as well as conducting our customary great summer camp. In addition, we were “rocking” camp with a “dig” lead by Penn State University and our Archeology merit badge program that summer. Thanks to film mogul Damon Sinclair (whose current day TV filming includes those on Philadelphia’s past and present); we have a great record of the Buzzards Rock “dig” that summer. All enjoyed the presentation and what it revealed about the history of that part of our camp. Also, credit goes to Rich Foote who did the sound work.

Archaeologists from the state gave a technical name to the location … The Horseshoe Rock Shelter which we call Buzzards Rock. The story revealed in the video mentioned that Native American Indians were out hunting looking for game and apparently stopped to use it for an overnight camping ground, mainly, because the rock formation provided weather cover. These Native Americans used it for around 15,000 years; and, of course, our Horseshoe Boy Scouts used it for around 85 years.

The Penn State people found a lot of Boy Scout remains at the site and many of the prehistoric Indian remains were mixed with those of the Scouts. What they found primarily were little broken chips from projectile points off of arrows and spears and also the pieces that were found after they sharpen their knives and cutting tools. Findings for the period between 1700 and 1730 included projectile point or arrowheads made of steel or copper. The archeologist believes these items were most likely made by the Susquehanna Indians who lived in this area made a metal arrowhead they would trade for from the Europeans. Indians would trade beaver pelts that were used for hats and for robes that were very popular at the time. For the metal items, things that look like Dutch ovens basically as well as hoes and axes were found.

As for that prehistoric period prior to Columbus’ discovery of America, one of the projectile points was made of a rock made of Pennsylvania Jasper, which the Indians would have had to travel up to or trade with the Indians near Veracruz, Pennsylvania. That one that they found is a complete artifact that is very unusual find. The archeologist felt that perhaps it could’ve fallen down a crack in some rocks and couldn’t be retrieved; therefore, the hunting party left it behind.

One of the more unusual things found was a piece of pottery that dated back to about 1200AD. It was a part of the rim of the top of a jar that probably was broken and then the pieces were left behind.

The spear points they found made of Quartz and Argillite, a stone found in Bucks County, indicates that again our natives would have had traded with the Native Americans from there to get that stone or perhaps traveled there … a large complete point was found by our Boy Scouts… Clark Green, past Camp Director, used it to pique the interest of the archaeology department of the State Museum of Pennsylvania. And, thus they came and spent 6 weeks at Camp Horseshoe to do the dig.

Before clay they made pots out of soapstone or steatite around 3000 BC. Again, they found a part of a small pot that would have been used for cooking. With little grooves on it. Some more points were found about the site going to the early archaic period. Dates somewhere between 6000 BC to 8000 BC 8000 to 10,000 years ago or more. Another interesting item they found the end part of a smoking tobacco pipe. Often they would use a mixture of tobacco and other leaves which they called kninack. One of the other finds that was so exciting for them … from the Palo period what would you describe it as either a bead or a button they would’ve used on their buckskin outfits again very unusual find.

They also found some projectile points or arrowheads that apparently were salted on the site some years back to increase the interest of young Boys Scouts. What raised questions were stones were not nearly hard enough and the Native Americans would never use serpentine. As Mark said “No Indian his right mind would make a projectile point out of a stone like serpentine.” The Scoutmaster’s name associated with this was Ernie Heegard.

(Editor JB’s note: At one time (circa 1946 -48 period) I recall that there was an extensive collection of arrow and spear points as well as other artifacts found on the Horseshoe property in our camp’s earlier years that resided in the Spellman White House.)

Following a great barbecue and desert, songs were enjoyed and plaudits given for the films all enjoyed. A brief business meeting concluded our Reunion.

“… I salute you; I ask that you do not return that salute.” A familiar phrase, to honor our Camp Leaders, who have made a difference to the Horseshoe Scout Reservation and the youth and leaders who devote their time and talents to the success of our Camps!

Allen K. Forssmark celebrated his 50th year as a member of the Boy Scouts of America. He earned the rank of Eagle Scout with a silver palm. As a Scout, Al attended two National Jamborees, one World Jamboree in Japan, National Junior Leader Training at Schiff Scout Reservation, and served on Camp Jubilee’s staff in the maintenance department. A graduate of Cheney University with a degree in Industrial Arts. Al is a truly one of our Reservation’s finest volunteers. A plaque was presented by Mark Hammond, HSRAA Chairman in recognition of Al’s great service.

Lee McIlvaine was honored as an active Unit Leader with a “Connection to Horseshoe’s History – Past and Present – A Scouting Family!” People ask Lee what his relationship is to McIlvaine Lodge. And…yes…there is a connection. Just ask him and you’ll learn some interesting information about our Horseshoe history.

Lee’s Scouting started in 1958 as a Cub Scout in Pack 65 in Exton. His first year at camp was 1964 with Troop 65 in Octoraro campsite. The next year with Troop 65, he spent a week at Camp Jubilee and stayed over the second week at Horseshoe. In June 1966 he took his OA Ordeal. Later that June found him taking the very first JLTC class in Council at Jubilee. He returned to Troop 65 as ASM in 1979, and became SM of Troop 65. His troop continued activities at camp and usually staying at Jubilee. In 1980 Lee took Wood badge training at then Camp Jubilee. He was presented his plaque for his continuing fine service as his family looked on.

Dr. Dave Mellinger, Horseshoe’s Morrison Health Lodge tending to our camper and staff health needs. Actually, his Scouting roots are in our Council where he has served on both Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware, 3rd staffs and as a camper.

This is Dave’s 30th year as a member of the HSR staff. He joined the staff at Camp Jubilee in 1981 as Archery Director. In 1982 he was Program Director and 1983-88 was the Camp Director. He has been at Camp Horseshoe in the Health Lodge since 1997. He goes on… “Some of my fondest memories and best friends resulted because of my affiliation with the camp. I am grateful that my current job has allowed me to return five weeks this summer – one of the highlights of my year.” Currently, Dave’s medical work has been that of working in the Department of Pediatrics in charge of Student Health Services at Duke University. Dave’s Mother and Father were on hand to witness his recognition…

Craig Hadden, HSRAA member, led the Council’s 100th Celebration in 2010. Council participation was strong in the year-long series of 100th events which included: Century of Values Tour presentation; the Council Recognition dinner in February; A “Gathering of Eagles” event; The Grand Centennial Parade in Washington, DC leading up to the National Jamboree 100th event and its Shining Light Across America; “Retro” merit badge offerings at summer camp; The Council’s Fall Camporee in October with over 1600 Scouts and leaders attending; and, the grand highlight event… the Gala at the Rivercrest Golf Club capping the 100th Year!

And, of course, one of the key components of the 100th was The Horseshoe Scout Reservation Alumni Association’s dedication of its 11th reunion in July to Horseshoe’s Scoutmasters and Leaders. A “Trail of Leadership” identified those selected for the Hall of Leadership recognition with descriptive information about each person. Many leaders were on hand (a compendium of photos are included on the following pages). This included Past Council Presidents Bob Lorgus, JB Rettew, Hab Butler, Dolores Hagerstrom, Blake Prichard, Russ Neubauer and 2011- elect Bill Taylor. While the day had a bit of “Horseshoe Dew” all enjoyed reuniting at the best attended Reunion.

On Saturday, July 18, 2009, the Tenth Annual Reunion of the HSRAA was one of our biggest yet with over 150 Alumni gathered for the celebration, a great BBQ meal and entertainment! “Heegard-Rettew Day” was a great success, enjoyed by the returning Alumni and especially Ernie and JB! Members of Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware 3rd from past generations were on hand for their traditional Class Pictures.

Returning Alumni had opportunities to tour camp, see the Aquatics meet at the pool; to enjoy reuniting with other HSRAA members and retell stories of their past camp days (slightly embellished over the years!). Bob Matje, Reunion Chairman, along with Stu Watson delivered a great time for all. There was song and food, great pig roast for attendees, opportunities to tour both Horseshoe and Ware camps, trade patches, view memorabilia of the “olden” days, videos, slides, etc. and to have a great time!

Ernie and JB were particularly happy when a contemporary of theirs joined in the celebration. Ron Sykes who had served on the Horseshoe Staff in the 1940’s returned to pay respects to the honorees. Ron had been the HQ Director and the Handicraft Director in his early days. He also served as Camp OA Sakima and was a representative to an early National OA Conclave.

The HSRAA formalities started off in the late afternoon with a tribute to the memory of Jim Gawthrop. Among the tributes were those from Fred Gates, Bill Waxbom, Andy Fish, John Souder, Ernie Heegard, JB, Bob Matje and others. Jim had served as Troop 53 Scoutmaster and the OA Lodge 22 for many years as an Advisor. He had been a Horseshoe camper from the early 40’s.

Following the Gawthrop memorial tributes, all joined in the evening Flag Retreat Ceremony. After the lowering of the flag, the Senior Patrol leaders were called on to put their troops “at ease”. Upon the American Flag being folded, it was carried and presented to Ernie Heegard by Noah Austin as the voice over the “P.A.” related the outstanding accomplishments of Ernie Heegard as he was formally presented with the Flag in his honor. This was shortly followed by a tribute to JB for his service to the Horseshoe Scout Reservation and the Chester County Council, BSA. He was presented with the Flag of Chester County Council, BSA by Staff member Graham Lenker of Devon 50.

Following the sumptuous pig roast supper, and a song lead by Ernie, special tributes to JB and Ernie were presented. Among those presenters were Bill Lenker, John Kemmerer, Bob Matje, Stu Watson, Board Member Ken Tunnell, Steve D’Antonio, John Souder, Chris Rettew, Neil Chippendale, and Bill Waxbom among many others…

In all it was a great evening and celebration of two men who have served the Council and Camps for over 65 years each!

It was a typical July day at Camp Horseshoe – a lot of heat and humidity – but nothing to keep the attendees hopping and stomping to the renditions of their favorite Sump Pumps on their retro-return to Camp. This year they were “unplugged and flowing.” In addition, the HSRA alumni and their friends were treated to the songs of the Horseshoe Staff chorus? melodious singing a capella.

That afternoon, Maureen Millman, retiring Council office worker (who worked tirelessly for the troops? camping reservations, etc.) was feted for her service at her retirement party with the HSRAA. A number of speeches recognized her many years of experience and she was presented by Bill Taylor, Council Commissioner, with a Richard Bollinger print of the Lane Farm house now the home of Roy Cole in his retirement.

Prior to the evening Retreat ceremony, the infamous “class pictures” were taken and appear in this issue…My…but no one seems to have changed a bit from one year to the next!

A sumptuous supper of roast pig was enjoyed by all after which our spirits were lifted by Ernie Heegard’s inspired song-leadership. Camp songs always get everyone chiming in regardless of their vocal qualities!

The business meeting was short and sweet as elections were held to form the new HSRAA Executive Committee for 2008 – 2009. Later, Mark Hammond was elected Chairman.

Our 8th HSRAA Reunion on July 15, 2007 at Camp John H. Ware, 3rd celebrated the Camp’s 50th Anniversary and the 80th Anniversary of the Horseshoe Scout Reservation! “Bill Robertson Day” honored Bill’s longtime service from the early days as an Explorer Base to its current prominence as Camp John H. Ware, 3rd.

The day was highlighted with HSRAA’s funded new Archery Pavilion being used for the first time. In addition, Paul Ware, son of Senator John H. Ware. 3rd and Past President of the Pennsylvania Dutch Area Council welcomed all and remarked on his family’s long-time involvement with the Chester County Council and the Reservation. Mark Hammond, HSRAA Chairman, greeted all and invited them to enjoy the sumptuous supper to top off a day of renewing friendships and relating some “tall” tales!

Thanks to the return of Horseshoe’s own “Sump Pumps!” July 9, 2006 was the largest turnout for an HSRAA reunion in its sevenyear history. After a great supper, the reunioners settled in to singing songs lead by Ernie Heegard, an auction of old camp Scout Law signs lead by Clarke Green and an evening filled with comedy and song provided by the popular “Sump Pumps”.

One cannot applaud more the effort put forth by our past Camp Staffers that Saturday evening.

The members of the “Sump Pumps” came from as far away as Virginia, Tennessee and California. Organized by Bill Grubb playing the “saw”, the group in the “No Flames in Tents” concert included Rev. Jim Goudie on guitar, John Sauser on the washboard and kazoo, Dave Kline on the washtub, along with the “strong” vocals and kazooing by Yogi Moyer, Phil Schwabb, Bill Pierson, and Steve D’Antonio. Sharp witty humor of Jim Goudie and “Rusty” among others keynoted the performance. Eric Lorgus introduced the group in witty style. Yes, and Jim Goudie’s friend, “Rusty” was there with his humorous back and forth “go ’round” delighting all.

Bill Grubb worked putting together this year’s “concert” with loyal Sump Pumpers of old. Thanks to Bill and all our old friends for another memorable event!

Thanks, too, to Chris Minshall, the Reunion committee leader who delivered a great time for all. Special HSRAA reunion T-Shirts were available and will be at future events.

Eagle Scout and former Horseshoe Staff member, Jeff Balmat, attending the Reunion from Arizona talked of his returning to the Horseshoe Scout Reservation and about some of his exploratory work on the past history of the property that now makes up the Reservation.

Jeff’s article in the Fall 2006 Octoraro Loop forms a background of his studies and is a preamble to his future articles about our beloved property.

July 16, 2005 is a date that may long be remembered in the annals of the Horseshoe Scout Reservation Alumni Association Reunions! This affair brought together campers and staff members of Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware 3rd from earlier generations. HSRAA member Jim Matthews, Master of Ceremonies, introduced the “Sump Pumps” with these stirring words:

“…Scouts, former scouts and non-scouts, this is the moment you’ve been waiting for. If you’ve never seen the Sump Pumps before, thank your lucky stars. But tonight be prepared to be dazzled and thrilled by Horseshoe’s own, world famous, Sump Pumps. Tonight they’ve taken time out of their enormously successful Lil Freezes Over Tour to perform here at the camp to commemorate their roots here. Because they are so successful and loved, I don’t need to tell you about the Sump Pumps, but I will. The Sump Pumps performed at Camp Horseshoe from ’66 to ’81 and then went on world tours. The Sumps have been together for 40 years now…however, most of that time they’ve been separated. You could say the group has evolved after being together so long. You could say it but it wouldn’t make it true. They are just as fresh and immature as they were when they started.”

Alumni commented: “This brought back many old memories of the opening campfires at summer camp of those days in the 1960’s, 70’s and 80’s.” “…fun times…not necessarily politically correct in today’s world!” “Let your hair down, boot kickin’ music and fun!” “One of the best reunions we had!” “Bring ’em back…!” Will they return? Check the coming issues of the Octoraro Loop about happenings on July 8, 2006. George Tzanakis and Chris Minshall were the Reunion Committee leaders and set up a great time for all. Special HSRAA reunion T-Shirts were available. There was song and food – great barbecue for attendees – opportunities to tour both Horseshoe and Ware and the official business meeting.

Returning “Sump Pump” alumni from 40+ years ago included: Rev .Jim Goudie and his “friend” Rusty Morgan, Dave “Yogi” Moyer, Dave Kline, John Souder, Bob Berhle, Fred Page and Jim Matthews. The instruments were finely tuned – a wash board, tub with broom handle and rope, pans, and you name it! Yes, there were guitars, harmonicas and other traditional musical devices. These skilled musicians sang such rousing songs like – Mountain Dew, Dirty Lil, Washington at Valley Forge, their “Full Medley (If you sprinkle, she’s got freckles, Laredo), Papa’s On The Housetop, Beedle Um Bum, among others.

The highlight of the 5th Annual Reunion of the HSRAA was the welcome afforded Rev. Edward C. “Casey” Jones upon his return to the Horseshoe Scout Reservation on July 10, 2004.

Casey’s tenure with Horseshoe as a camper and staff member spanned three decades beginning in 1941 and lasting until 1961. Many years have passed since Casey was last in Camp. He was taken by the marked changes in the physical parts of camp – new campsites, headquarters, Parade Field headwall, and many other items. However, he also noted that while the physical characteristics had changed, the spirit of camp and its mission as well as the Enthusiasm of the Scouts was as he recalled from his earlier days.

Many who attended Horseshoe as campers or staffers during his years in camp returned to greet Casey. Among them were Fred Gates, Len and Tom McCabe, Bill Lenker, JB Rettew, Bill Waxbom, Roland Minshall, Roland Smith, Bill Trowill, Herb Warner, Jim Dukovic and many others.

Casey and many others that day were treated to a tour of the new facilities at Camp John H. Ware, 3rd. As Casey recalled that part of the Reservation, it was called the “Explorer Base” in the early days and then Camp Jubilee. The new Cub Camp facilities were impressive as was the new Ware Staff campsite.

All had a good opportunity to tour Horseshoe before the evening Retreat Ceremony. This was the first opportunity for many HSRAA alums to see the headwall for the Parade Field and the new troop flag standards that had been funded by the HSRAA membership dues and other contributions. Camp was filled to capacity and needless to say there was not too much more room on the field. The OA Tapout ceremony recalled the days when Casey Jones was a member of the Tapout team in costumes somewhat ‘briefer’ than those worn at the ceremony.

Following a fine meal arranged for by George Tzanakis, Reunion Chairman, HSRAA Chairman Bob Matje greeted the alumni and friends. Bob and the HSRAA with a commemorative certificate honored “Casey” Jones. JB Rettew and Bill Lenker were called upon and recognized the impact that Casey had on their lives and the campers during his tenure.

As part of the business meeting Chairman Matje presented special certificates of merit to Dick Bensing for his work in the HSRAA projects of the headwall and the gateways for both camps, and, to JB Rettew for his five years of work on the Octoraro Loop. Plans were reviewed for the further addition to the Parade Field project.

All are looking forward to the 2005 Reunion.

On July 12, 2003, the fourth annual Reunion of the Horseshoe Scout Reservation Alumni Association (HSRAA) brought together over 100 Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware, III alumni/ae at Camp Horseshoe. George Tzanakis, Chairman of the event enthusiastically commented … “It did not disappoint!” Friendships were renewed, camp stories retold (with embellishments), pictures taken of young and old; and there was much laughter and a few tears as representatives of every decade of the Reservation convened at Kindness Center.

Many pioneer campers were there. Tom Gillingham, 90+ years old, who had camped at the Council’s Camp Rothrock in the 1920’s, is a 1926 Eagle Scout and was on the Horseshoe Staff when camp opened in 1928, enjoyed the fellowship and festivities along with his son, Frank, who journeyed from California. Tom also was the Camp Horseshoe doctor for many years. From the 1930’s decade were Roland Minshall ’32 followed by those of the 1940’s that included Roland Smith ’44, Fred Gates ’44, John Rettew ’44, Ernie Heegard ’46 and Bill Trowill ’48. Each of the subsequent decades was well represented.

Camp Ware Director Jim Montich was reunited with former Ware (Jubilee) directors Matt Christenson and Dr. Dave Mellinger. Dave, from Wisconsin, while Matt flew in from Idaho. They joined past Horseshoe CD’s Ernie Heegard and Clarke Green.

The day’s events included tours of both Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware, III conducted by Alumni committee members. Interesting Scouting memorabilia of early camp days was enjoyed, as were the old photos, videos of camp and the Reunion Issue of “The Octoraro Loop”, HSRAA’s newsletter. Decade photos were taken.

In the afternoon, all alumni/ae gathered with current Horseshoe staff and friends, to pay tribute to Bill “Biff” Davis at the Rothrock campsite in the dedication of a new pavilion constructed in his memory. Opening prayers and remarks were made by Reverend Gary Marshall followed by the Flag Ceremony and comments by HSRAA Chairman Bob Matje. Biff’s widow, Sharon, extended her thanks and appreciation for the support that the HSRAA had given her and the family as well as the family’s appreciation of the pavilion erected in Biff’s memory. She then unveiled the drape from the commemorative plaque. “Taps” was sounded by the Color Guard from the Camp.

The evening Retreat Ceremony including an Order of the Arrow “call-out” of candidates was memorable. As our alumni/ae stood “tall” at Retreat, Camp Director Mike Berkeihiser reviewed the troops and all HSRAA members adjourned to Kindness Center for a sumptuous barbecue of beef and venison and fellowship.

This was the third Annual convention of alumni/ae from Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H Ware 3rd. Bill “Biff” Davis was in charge of the daylong event and the great program. A fine catered dinner capped the event and kept all in a fine mood for the camp songs and reminiscences led by Ernie Heegard and Clarke Green.

Attendees were greeted by streamers and banners at Goodman Pavillion and by HSRAA greeters. Alumni representing most of the decades were there to join in the fun and fellowship of the day. Many activities were arranged for the Alumni this year. Events enjoyed were the open rifle shoots and hikes to the swimming pool to watch the Aquatics meet. The camp staff erected a giant swing that captured the fascination of many stalwarts including Council Commissioner Russ Neubauer and many more youthful attendees.

A nostalgic slide show of Camp Horseshoe days from 1927 to present day were viewed along with those of early Camp Ware (then Jubilee) days and the present.

Leonard McCabe of the 1940’s showed up with some memorabilia which he presented to JB Rettew. It was the envelope and message from the “Message to Garcia” game played on Flagpole Hill on August 10the in 1942. Len asked – “Is Garcia still waiting for the message?” (see editor’s note on last page.) Then, he also produced the “the mine claim” that he and his patrol had staked out in the Octoraro Creek at the Camp Horseshoe ‘Gold Rush’ in 1945.

Ron Walter came to the Reunion representing the 1950’s. Before the event, his father, T. Edgar Walter, Jr. had sent him a letter about his 1927 and later years’ experiences at Camp Horseshoe. He wrote of the day he joined “Chief” Heistand, his Scoutmaster Harold Schramm, his father, and others to visit the “new property” that was to become our Camp Horseshoe. What a great time that must have been for this twelve year old and now age 87 to relive some of those days through his son, Ron. Ron also produced the well known camp post card photo showing him in Indian costume being paddled in a canoe to the “Bend in the Octoraro.”

There were patches and old uniforms, copies of old “Camp Echo” newspapers, slides and movies and other ancient and honorable relics of an earlier day. But, the best part of the Reunion was the opportunity to reunite with campers and Staff members of the past from Horseshoe and Ware and to reflect on those halcyon days of our youth.

The Reunion included a sumptuous barbecue feast following the evening Camp Retreat ceremony. This was probably one of the largest summer camp Retreat ceremony held at camp. The Parade Field was bulging at the seams with Scouts, Leaders, Staff, Parents and Alumni! We can take great pride in the fact that all of those and us assembled had a lot to do with keeping our Council’s summer camping program among the best in the Nation.

On July 21, 2001, the second annual Reunion of the Horseshoe Scout Reservation Alumni Association (HSRAA) saw over 70 Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware III alumni/ae at Camp Horseshoe. There was laughter, stories and great fellowship as alums from every decade convened in the Goodman Pavilion from all over the United States.

Pioneer campers were there. Link Rice, who claimed considering his father-in-law Albert Smith, that he was one of five generations of Horseshoe campers from his family! Link had come to Camp Horseshoe as a camper, the first year it had opened in 1928. He was there with other generations of his family to enjoy the fellowship and festivities. His great grandson Josh Hughes was serving on the Horseshoe staff.

From the 1930’s decade was Merce Sloan ’30 and J. Edgar “Gumps” McComsey ’32 followed by those of the 1940’s that included: Fred Gates ’44, John Rettew ’44, Ernie Heegard ’46 and Bill “Curley” Trowill ’46. Each of the subsequent decades was well represented. Bill Jackson ’53, Herb Warner ’57, Gerald Kevis, Jim Dukovic ’54 and E. Gary Marshall ’55 re p resented the 1950’s. Matt Christenson ’67 came one of the longest distances – Boise, Idaho. Other members of the 60’s did not trek as far – Frank Rodgers ’67, Steve Brun ’63, Frank DiMarzio ’68 and Eric Lorgus. The 1970’s had 14 back; the 1980’s 18; the 1990’s and the 2000’s were well represented with 17. Along with Dr. Dave Mellinger, were many Horseshoe Staffers of 2001 and Ray Hayden, new Camp Ranger and his wife, Donna. Also, Roy Cole, the third in a line of four generations of the Cole Family to serve as Camp Ranger, was on hand with his wife Matleen enjoying the activities.

The day’s events included tours of both Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware III conducted by Alumni committee members. Specially designed HSRAA “T” shirts had been presented to the Horseshoe and Ware staff members and were available for the Reunion attendees. Interesting Scouting memorabilia of early camp days was enjoyed as were the old photos, videos of camp and the July ’01 Reunion Issue of “The Octoraro Loop” Association newsletter. Decade photos were taken. The evening Retreat Ceremony including an Order of the Arrow “call-out” of candidates was memorable, as our alumni/ae stood “tall” at Retreat. Following the fine barbecue supper arranged for by Biff Davis, Clarke Greene served as Master of Ceremonies and Ernie Heegard then stepped into his familiar role as song leader. Popular camp songs were sung leading up to the rousing “Green Grow The Rushes, Ho!” Then, former Horseshoe Camp Director Clarke Green spoke of Horseshoe and Camp Ware and recounted some of the returning alumni/ae statistics – Rev. Gary Marshall had come from Roanoke, VA and would be giving the Sermon at the Horseshoe Chapel on Sunday; Jeff Balmat came from Louisiana, Matt Christenson from Idaho, Joe Eagan from Massachusetts. Link Rice was the earliest camper.

Bob Matje, Chairman of the HSRAA, greeted alumni/ae, family, friends and current staff members and convened the business meeting. He expressed his thanks and appreciation to Bill “Biff” Davis, Reunion Chairman and organizer of the event, for his successful efforts. Bob spoke of the success of the HSRAA that now boasts over 300 members – a credit to the strong values of the Horseshoe Reservation ties and programs. Council Executive Doug Dillow then spoke of his appreciation for the rich and vital heritage that the HSRAA and the Reunion represented to Chester County Council and future generations of Scout campers.

Special projects undertaken by the HSRAA were discussed. The first funded by the Association was the “Harris Poll’ for the Council – a study of Scouting vitality in our Council in cooperation with the National BSA. Dick Bensing, Projects Leader of the HSRAA, spoke of the near completion of the Camp Horseshoe gate project and plans for special gateway for Camp John H. Ware III.

Elections were held for the new HSRAA Executive Committee to serve from September 1, 2001 until August 31, 2002. Elected were: Dick Bensing, Hab Butler, Neil Chippendale, Bill Davis, Joe Eagan, Ron Fish, J.B. Fischer, Rich Foot, Eric Lorgus, Bob Matje, Jim Matthews, III, Lee McIlvaine, John ‘JB’ Rettew, Bruce Robertson and Andy Smith.

The meeting was concluded with the reminder: the Third Annual Reunion will be Saturday, July 13, 2002.

Following the meeting, the group adjourned to the Horseshoe Camp Road where the new gateway, funded by the HSRAA, had been constructed. The imposing structure was erected prior to the opening of summer camp. The stone work in which the uprights had been placed was impressive as well as the beam to support the camp sign. A ribbon marked the gateway entrance. While the throng of HSRAA members gathered about, Council Executive Doug Dillow, Board Member Bill Taylor and HSRAA Chairman Bob Matje presented appropriate remarks followed by the ribbon cutting ceremony.

On July 8, 2000, the first annual Reunion of the Horseshoe Scout Reservation Alumni Association (HSRAA) brought together over 100 Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware, III alumni/ae at Camp Horseshoe. It did not disappoint! Friendships were renewed, camp stories retold (with embellishments), pictures taken of young and old; and there was much laughter and a few tears as representatives of every decade of the Reservation convened in the newly constructed Goodman Pavilion.

Many pioneer campers were there. Link Rice, who is the first of four generations of Horseshoe campers and had attended Camp Horseshoe the first year it had opened in 1928, enjoyed the fellowship and festivities. From the 1930’s decade were Roland Minshall ’32 and Bob Lorgus ’36 followed by those of the 1940’s that included Jim Gawthrop ’41, Fred Gates ’44, John Rettew ’44, Ernie Heegard ’46 and Bill Trowill ’48. Each of the subsequent decades was well represented. Along with Marjie Prosock, current Camp John H. Ware, III Director, former Ware Directors attending the Reunion were Dr. Dave Mellinger, C.W. Bruton and Paul Owens. Roy Cole, the third in a line of four generations of the Cole Family to serve as Camp Ranger, was on hand with his wife Matleen enjoying the activities.

The day’s events included tours of both Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware, III conducted by Alumni committee members. Interesting Scouting memorabilia of early camp days was enjoyed as were the old photos, videos of camp and the Reunion Issue of “The Octoraro Loop”, HSRAA’s newsletter. Decade photos were taken – and, oh my! how some of us had aged since those early days at camp! The evening Retreat Ceremony including an Order of the Arrow “call-out” of candidates was memorable. As our alumni/ae stood “tall” at Retreat, Camp Director Mike Berkeihiser ceremoniously turned over the review of the troops to Camp Director Emeritus Ernie Heegard.

Following a fine “Camp Ware-style chicken barbecue” supper, Ernie then stepped into his familiar role as song leader. Popular camp songs were sung leading up to the rousing “Green Grow The Rushes, Ho!” Then, former Horseshoe Camp Director Clarke Green spoke of Horseshoe and Camp Ware and recounted some of the returning alumni/ae statistics – Rev. Gary Marshall had come the longest distance from Roanoke, VA beating out Joe Eagan from Boston; Link Rice was the earliest camper, etc.

Bob Matje, Chairman of the HSRAA, greeted 120 alumni/ae, family, friends and current staff members and convened the business meeting. He expressed his thanks and appreciation to Bill “Biff” Davis, Reunion Chairman and organizer of the event, for his successful efforts as well as to the Bruton brothers and other Camp Ware alumni who prepared the fine meal. Council Executive Doug Dillow ’97 spoke of his awe and appreciation of the rich and vital heritage that the HSRAA and the Reunion represented to Chester County Council and future generations of Scout campers.

Special projects undertaken by the HSRAA were discussed. The first one undertaken by the Association and nearing completion was that of the “Harris Poll’ for the Council – a study of Scouting vitality in our Council in cooperation with the National BSA. Dick Bensing ’57, Projects Leader of the HSRAA, presented plans for special gateways for both Camp Horseshoe and Camp John H. Ware, III. It is felt that these projects will help to define our Association’s mission that by providing capital improvements having significance for the Reservation and setting a high standard for the HSRAA.

Elections were held for the new HSRAA Executive Committee to serve from September 1, 2000 until August 31, 2001. Elected were: Dick Bensing, Mike Berkeihiser, Hab Butler, Neil Chippendale, Bill Davis, Joe Eagan, Ron Fish, Karen Griffin, Eric Lorgus, Bob Matje, Paul Owens, John ‘JB’ Rettew, Andy Smith, John Souder and Harold Weber, Sr. These Scouters were unanimously elected. The meeting was concluded with the reminder that the next Reunion would be on the corresponding camp weekend in July 2001.

For more pictures from the 2019 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2018 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2017 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2016 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2015 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2014 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2013 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2012 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2011 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2010 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2009 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2007 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2006 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2005 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2004 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2003 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2002 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2001 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.

For more pictures from the 2000 HSRAA Reunion, click HERE to go to the display in the Virtual Museum.